/ Politics / ECHR Ruling: Azerbaijan Violated the Convention by Releasing Ramil Safarov

ECHR Ruling: Azerbaijan Violated the Convention by Releasing Ramil Safarov



Լրահոս

Turkey is to blame for ongoing conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh: Armenian PM
1.11.2020 | 22:17   ***
Turkey is to blame for ongoing conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh: Armenian ...
Demonstration held in Los Angeles amid hostilities on Armenia-Azerbaijan border (video)
22.07.2020 | 10:20   ***
Demonstration held in Los Angeles amid hostilities on Armenia-Azerbaij...
ArmnewsOnline TV Youtube chanel
Hundreds of Troops Gather in DC to Defend and Protect Monuments
28.06.2020 | 10:11   ***
Hundreds of Troops Gather in DC to Defend and Protect Monuments
Swedish website reveals new documents about Erdogan’s involvement in recruiting terrorists in Syria
13.06.2020 | 3:12   ***
Swedish website reveals new documents about Erdogan’s involvement in r...
Greece, Cyprus, Armenia block Turkey's candidacy to head U.N. General Assembly
13.06.2020 | 0:35   ***
Greece, Cyprus, Armenia block Turkey's candidacy to head U.N. General ...
Greece and Egypt prepare to block Turkish expansion in Mediterranean
12.06.2020 | 3:09   ***
Greece and Egypt prepare to block Turkish expansion in Mediterranean
General Floros’ message to Turkey: We are ready to crush anyone who underestimates us
5.06.2020 | 15:55   ***
General Floros’ message to Turkey: We are ready to crush anyone who un...
 Armenians in Yerevan show solidarity with Black Lives Matter campaign
5.06.2020 | 1:53   ***
Armenians in Yerevan show solidarity with Black Lives Matter campaign
Canada stops military exports to Azerbaijan and bans arms sales to Turkey
5.06.2020 | 0:16   ***
Canada stops military exports to Azerbaijan and bans arms sales to Tur...
Monte Melkonian talks about Artsakh
1.06.2020 | 2:57   ***
Monte Melkonian talks about Artsakh
White House to Look at Petition To Investigate Bill Gates for ‘Crimes Against Humanity’; Gets
31.05.2020 | 19:18   ***
White House to Look at Petition To Investigate Bill Gates for ‘Crimes ...
Citizens of Armenia can travel to China without visa from June 1
30.05.2020 | 20:04   ***
Citizens of Armenia can travel to China without visa from June 1
Armenian peacekeepers making a significant contribution to stability and peace in the world
30.05.2020 | 10:30   ***
Armenian peacekeepers making a significant contribution to stability a...
Armenian mission completes de-mining of two minefields in Aleppo
29.05.2020 | 15:31   ***
Armenian mission completes de-mining of two minefields in Aleppo
ECHR Ruling: Azerbaijan Violated the Convention by Releasing Ramil Safarov
28.05.2020 | 12:57   ***
ECHR Ruling: Azerbaijan Violated the Convention by Releasing Ramil Saf...
Armenian Foreign Ministry congratulates Muslims on Eid Al Fitr
23.05.2020 | 23:48   ***
Armenian Foreign Ministry congratulates Muslims on Eid Al Fitr
2 top ISIS leaders killed in Syria
23.05.2020 | 3:10   ***
2 top ISIS leaders killed in Syria
U.S. NEWS 2 Michigan dams breached, thousands evacuated amid 'devastating' flooding
22.05.2020 | 12:00   ***
U.S. NEWS 2 Michigan dams breached, thousands evacuated amid 'devastat...
Erdogan Should be Tried by International Criminal Court for Supporting Terrorism
20.05.2020 | 21:55   ***
Erdogan Should be Tried by International Criminal Court for Supporting...
Azokh Cave of Artsakh Helps to Reveal the Secrets of Ancient People
20.05.2020 | 0:55   ***
Azokh Cave of Artsakh Helps to Reveal the Secrets of Ancient People
Armenia to set up production of buses jointly with Korean company
18.05.2020 | 21:38   ***
Armenia to set up production of buses jointly with Korean company
Libyan Army shoots 3rd Turkish aircraft in last 24 hours
11.05.2020 | 14:48   ***
Libyan Army shoots 3rd Turkish aircraft in last 24 hours
The German officers were part of the European border force (FRONTEX) which has deployed some 100 officers, among them 20 Germans, in Greece along the Evros border in March as part of the so-called RAPID intervention requested by Athens, when Turkey was pushing thousands of migrants toward Europe.
6.05.2020 | 5:25   ***
The German officers were part of the European border force (FRONTEX) w...
Armenian militia fighting Turkish invaders in Syria celebrates first anniversary
4.05.2020 | 19:57   ***
Armenian militia fighting Turkish invaders in Syria celebrates first a...
Middle East Airlines to operate Beirut-Yerevan flight on May 4
28.04.2020 | 17:12   ***
Middle East Airlines to operate Beirut-Yerevan flight on May 4
Turkish military attacks Syrian Army troops in northeast Syria
27.04.2020 | 19:42   ***
Turkish military attacks Syrian Army troops in northeast Syria
Armenia demands apology from Turkey on genocide anniversary
27.04.2020 | 2:36   ***
Armenia demands apology from Turkey on genocide anniversary
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's Message on the 105th Anniversary of the Armenian Genocide
26.04.2020 | 10:52   ***
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's Message on the 105th Anniversary of th...
Germany's plan to end the lockdown on April 19
15.04.2020 | 4:40   ***
Germany's plan to end the lockdown on April 19
Armenia has not requested Turkey’s assistance in fighting COVID-19 – MFA
13.04.2020 | 21:37   ***
Armenia has not requested Turkey’s assistance in fighting COVID-19 – M...
Բոլորը

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) today ruled in the case of Gurgen Margaryan, an Armenian army lieutenant who was axed to death in Budapest in 2004 by Ramil Safarov, an  Azerbaijani army lieutenant.

 

The two were in Hungary to participate in a NATO sponsored English language training course. Ain 2006, a Budapest court sentenced Safarov to life imprisonment. Hungarian authorities released him to Azerbaijani authorities in 2012, so that he could spend the rest of his sentence there. Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev immediately pardoned him. Safarov was later promoted to the rank of major and provided with lodging and other perks.

Today, the ECHR issued a press release today on the ruling entitled “Azerbaijan violated the Convention by releasing an extradited officer who had murdered an Armenian soldier during training in Hungary”.

The press release, in part, reads:

 The case “Makuchyan and Minasyan v. Azerbaijan and Hungary” (application no. 17247/13) concerned the presidential pardon given to a convicted murderer and his release following his transfer from Hungary to Azerbaijan to serve the rest of his sentence.

R.S., a military officer from Azerbaijan, killed an Armenian military officer and attempted to kill another one when they were attending a course in Hungary in 2004. The case also concerned more generally the hero’s welcome given to R.S. in Azerbaijan upon his return.

In today’s Chamber judgment1 in the case the European Court of Human Rights held:

by six votes to one, that there had been no substantive violation by Azerbaijan of Article 2 (right to life) of the European Convention on Human Rights;

unanimously, that there had been a procedural violation by Azerbaijan of Article 2 of the Convention;

 by six votes to one, that there had been no procedural violation by Hungary of Article 2; by six votes to one, that there had been a violation by Azerbaijan of Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) taken in conjunction with Article 2, and

 unanimously, that neither the Azerbaijani nor Hungarian Governments had failed to comply with Article 38 (obligation to furnish necessary facilities for the examination of the case).

The Court found that although Azerbaijan had clearly endorsed R.S.’s acts, not only by releasing him but also by promoting him, paying him salary arrears and granting him a flat upon his return, it could not be held responsible under the stringent standards of international law which required a State to “acknowledge” such acts “as its own”.

Moreover, those acts had been part of a private decision and had been so flagrantly abusive and far removed from the official status of a military officer that the Court could not see how his commanding officers could have foreseen them or how Azerbaijan could be responsible for them just because he was a State agent. However, it found that there had been no justification for the Azerbaijani authorities’ failure to enforce the punishment of R.S. and to in effect grant him impunity for a serious hate crime.

Նյութի աղբյուր՝ hetq.am
Հավանեցի՞ք նյութը, կիսվեք ընկերների հետ։


Կարող եք կիսվել Ձեր տպավորությամբ

0 0 0 0 0 0